Mar 16, 2010 - mma? if im not mistaken that guy seems Kyokushin karate plus wrestling (yellow belt in kyokushin is before brownbelt)
jav2512 Shkruan:
Mar 16, 2010 - im a karate shotokan brown belt and i have training 1yr bjj and mma, i beat many mma figthers in my gym, but i stop my karate training because i think we spend a lot of time doing katas. now i like more mma and bjj. any way karate have some good tecniques and i like the karate timing and strikes..
originaleplejus911 Shkruan:
Mar 14, 2010 - To be completely honest, karate is too one-sided compared to MMA fighting. Having a good ground game is essential for being a good martial artist, when approx 90% of the fights within mixed martial arts go to the ground.MMA stands for "Mixed Martial Arts" and most of the fighters there have experience in both stand up fight(muy thai, karate like you and me) and grappling. Saying that Karate is better than MMA would be the same as saying that "its better to brush your teeth without toothpaste".
aria1993 Shkruan:
Mar 13, 2010 - black belt in karate and mma for 3 years at the moment. ur not wrong completely, some karate fighters would beat mma fighters, but vice versa can happen as well. its all about the fighter.
RebornGuitarLearner Shkruan:
Mar 12, 2010 - Fellas... It's man beats man. Not style beats style.
iloveaxxo Shkruan:
Mar 6, 2010 - @multigunlover krav maga ios king without rules....in my experience karate classes i have been to have been useless...more about stretching than fighting but the mma/sub wrestling i wen to was stuff you could apply straight away
multigunlover Shkruan:
Mar 5, 2010 - im saying without rules
iloveaxxo Shkruan:
Mar 5, 2010 - @multigunlover not in both but if karate would beat mma why is the ufc champion not a pure karate fighter
slater58 Shkruan:
Feb 27, 2010 - karate huh?? what stye? this guys stance and form are a joke.
senseifrazier Shkruan:
Feb 27, 2010 - Sloppy technique, this vid doesnt need a comment, but Russians are tough.
coldworld5 Shkruan:
Feb 23, 2010 - @multigunlover your wrong,your an idiot,any one with basic bjj ans wrestling would smash a bb in karate with in seconds.
multigunlover Shkruan:
Feb 23, 2010 - What the hell?!?!Gloves on someone in karate is not koolkarate would beat mma we have many more things we know .And yes im in karate and mma "so i know what im saying" dont tell me im wrong unless ur in both.
sammaggard Shkruan:
Feb 15, 2010 - I'm a black belt in Shorin Ryu Karate... if this guy is karate based.. i don't see it at all. Hes aweful.
MartialAiled Shkruan:
Feb 4, 2010 - I think he should avoid certain grapple positions when going up against a MMA fighter because most of them seem to have a history of Brazilian Jui jutsu. The "Karate guy" seems like an idiot. Too much wasted rushes, wasted opportunities and predictable movements. (*sigh* He makes karate look bad =[ )
realbodizzle Shkruan:
Jan 30, 2010 - White Gi and his sick ass takedowns.
EngageTheKnot Shkruan:
Jan 29, 2010 - qith a nice red belt!
nicerebound Shkruan:
Jan 26, 2010 - certain styles also proved far more effective than others for certain aspects of combat, some arts have proven totally useless and others probably never existed before the chinese cultural revolution. styles often make the fighter tooput a student of 6 months at a serious muay thai gym against a student with a year of most any traditional art and watch the traditional guy get destroyed. a fighters general approach to training is the single most important factor in their fighting ability
audrey29tg Shkruan:
Jan 26, 2010 - i understand why you would be interested in the traditional vs traditional style debate and if im honest i find it to be interesting as well . i find it interesting in the same way one might view a classic car vs a modern car , its great for its time and still has a place but is somewhat un-evolved . i do recognize the importance of the classic traditional styles as the foundation for what we now have but i feel that in the end the evolved style wins most of the time.
nicerebound Shkruan:
Jan 25, 2010 - @ audrey - i agree with your assessment of the video and i wonder why they allowed so much groundfighting with boxing gloves. however, i still care about the style vs style arguments. the subject interests me because so many people still believe traditional styles can stand up by themselves against modern combat sports. im not sure what the losers in this video claim as their style but one thing is clear, the yellow belt won with sport/competition skills over a confused traditional artist
pcgamesolution Shkruan:
Jan 19, 2010 - the karate guy (black) really sucks ! look at how he attacks: launcing himself ahead. noob idiot
62Power Shkruan:
Jan 17, 2010 - looks like sambo
audrey29tg Shkruan:
Jan 9, 2010 - look people both fighters have closed gloves on so regardless of their styles ( unless it was boxing or kickboxing ) they are forced to fight with strikes ( sloppy ones i might add ) with the occasional sloppy take down. is it mma ? karate ? kick boxing ? who knows who cares . styles are just names there is no one better than another its all on the individual to be driven enough to make it work. are we still on with the bullshit arguing about styles ? really who cares.
MechPhantom Shkruan:
Dec 31, 2009 - the white is kyokushin serious u can see the japanese writing on the left of his chest
MechPhantom Shkruan:
Dec 31, 2009 - @slickvertigoflow yes correct smart !!
THOMASJOHNSEN818 Shkruan:
Dec 28, 2009 - Its "Muay tha" LOLOL can't even ground n pound.
Video Detaje
MMA ( White Gi ) vs Karate ( Black Gi ). Full contact .22.02.2009 Moscow. Russia. More
MMA ( White Gi ) vs Karate ( Black Gi ). Full contact .22.02.2009 Moscow. Russia. Less
Posto nje koment
Komentet Lokale (0)
Komente nga Youtube (90)
supernova92024 Shkruan:
Mar 16, 2010 - mma? if im not mistaken that guy seems Kyokushin karate plus wrestling (yellow belt in kyokushin is before brownbelt)
jav2512 Shkruan:
Mar 16, 2010 - im a karate shotokan brown belt and i have training 1yr bjj and mma, i beat many mma figthers in my gym, but i stop my karate training because i think we spend a lot of time doing katas. now i like more mma and bjj. any way karate have some good tecniques and i like the karate timing and strikes..
originaleplejus911 Shkruan:
Mar 14, 2010 - To be completely honest, karate is too one-sided compared to MMA fighting. Having a good ground game is essential for being a good martial artist, when approx 90% of the fights within mixed martial arts go to the ground.MMA stands for "Mixed Martial Arts" and most of the fighters there have experience in both stand up fight(muy thai, karate like you and me) and grappling. Saying that Karate is better than MMA would be the same as saying that "its better to brush your teeth without toothpaste".
aria1993 Shkruan:
Mar 13, 2010 - black belt in karate and mma for 3 years at the moment. ur not wrong completely, some karate fighters would beat mma fighters, but vice versa can happen as well. its all about the fighter.
RebornGuitarLearner Shkruan:
Mar 12, 2010 - Fellas... It's man beats man. Not style beats style.
iloveaxxo Shkruan:
Mar 6, 2010 - @multigunlover krav maga ios king without rules....in my experience karate classes i have been to have been useless...more about stretching than fighting but the mma/sub wrestling i wen to was stuff you could apply straight away
multigunlover Shkruan:
Mar 5, 2010 - im saying without rules
iloveaxxo Shkruan:
Mar 5, 2010 - @multigunlover not in both but if karate would beat mma why is the ufc champion not a pure karate fighter
slater58 Shkruan:
Feb 27, 2010 - karate huh?? what stye? this guys stance and form are a joke.
senseifrazier Shkruan:
Feb 27, 2010 - Sloppy technique, this vid doesnt need a comment, but Russians are tough.
coldworld5 Shkruan:
Feb 23, 2010 - @multigunlover your wrong,your an idiot,any one with basic bjj ans wrestling would smash a bb in karate with in seconds.
multigunlover Shkruan:
Feb 23, 2010 - What the hell?!?!Gloves on someone in karate is not koolkarate would beat mma we have many more things we know .And yes im in karate and mma "so i know what im saying" dont tell me im wrong unless ur in both.
sammaggard Shkruan:
Feb 15, 2010 - I'm a black belt in Shorin Ryu Karate... if this guy is karate based.. i don't see it at all. Hes aweful.
MartialAiled Shkruan:
Feb 4, 2010 - I think he should avoid certain grapple positions when going up against a MMA fighter because most of them seem to have a history of Brazilian Jui jutsu. The "Karate guy" seems like an idiot. Too much wasted rushes, wasted opportunities and predictable movements. (*sigh* He makes karate look bad =[ )
realbodizzle Shkruan:
Jan 30, 2010 - White Gi and his sick ass takedowns.
EngageTheKnot Shkruan:
Jan 29, 2010 - qith a nice red belt!
nicerebound Shkruan:
Jan 26, 2010 - certain styles also proved far more effective than others for certain aspects of combat, some arts have proven totally useless and others probably never existed before the chinese cultural revolution. styles often make the fighter tooput a student of 6 months at a serious muay thai gym against a student with a year of most any traditional art and watch the traditional guy get destroyed. a fighters general approach to training is the single most important factor in their fighting ability
audrey29tg Shkruan:
Jan 26, 2010 - i understand why you would be interested in the traditional vs traditional style debate and if im honest i find it to be interesting as well . i find it interesting in the same way one might view a classic car vs a modern car , its great for its time and still has a place but is somewhat un-evolved . i do recognize the importance of the classic traditional styles as the foundation for what we now have but i feel that in the end the evolved style wins most of the time.
nicerebound Shkruan:
Jan 25, 2010 - @ audrey - i agree with your assessment of the video and i wonder why they allowed so much groundfighting with boxing gloves. however, i still care about the style vs style arguments. the subject interests me because so many people still believe traditional styles can stand up by themselves against modern combat sports. im not sure what the losers in this video claim as their style but one thing is clear, the yellow belt won with sport/competition skills over a confused traditional artist
pcgamesolution Shkruan:
Jan 19, 2010 - the karate guy (black) really sucks ! look at how he attacks: launcing himself ahead. noob idiot
62Power Shkruan:
Jan 17, 2010 - looks like sambo
audrey29tg Shkruan:
Jan 9, 2010 - look people both fighters have closed gloves on so regardless of their styles ( unless it was boxing or kickboxing ) they are forced to fight with strikes ( sloppy ones i might add ) with the occasional sloppy take down. is it mma ? karate ? kick boxing ? who knows who cares . styles are just names there is no one better than another its all on the individual to be driven enough to make it work. are we still on with the bullshit arguing about styles ? really who cares.
MechPhantom Shkruan:
Dec 31, 2009 - the white is kyokushin serious u can see the japanese writing on the left of his chest
MechPhantom Shkruan:
Dec 31, 2009 - @slickvertigoflow yes correct smart !!
THOMASJOHNSEN818 Shkruan:
Dec 28, 2009 - Its "Muay tha" LOLOL can't even ground n pound.